Netanyahu: The boys were kidnapped by Hamas
After trying and failing to seize power through violence, political Islam has grown up from a bad boy into a responsible adult.
Just a year ago, the Muslim Brotherhood was an illegal organization in Egypt. Like his predecessors, Anwar Sadat and Gamal Nasser, President Hosni Mubarak kept tight control over religious organizations of every stripe, whether they engaged in underground military activity or if they sought to participate in the civil political process. Muslim Brotherhood activists who wanted to run in elections did so as independents.
Yesterday and today, with the opening of the polling stages for the first stage of elections to Egypt's lower house of Parliament, brought an end to an era in the history of the Muslim Brotherhood, which constantly strove to achieve power ever since it was founded in 1928. If the Muslim Brotherhood can achieve Demo-Islam - democracy and Islam - they have the ability to lead Egypt to the next stage. Anyone wondering whether the mix of religion and politics is possible does not have to look far - it is enough to look at Jerusalem.
The Muslim Brotherhood, which is now entering Egyptian politics through the front door, is not the organization of the stormy 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s. In 1949, they assassinated Egyptian Prime Minister Mahmoud an-Nukrashi Pasha, and King Farouk had the organization's founder, Sheikh Hassan al-Banna, killed in response. A year earlier, the Muslim Brotherhood sent men to fight in Palestine, where they could not resist the IDF or prevent the Nakba of Israel's independence and the Palestinians' catastrophe. A few years later, the Muslim Brotherhood tried to assassinate Nasser, who had the would-be assassins executed.
The Muslim Brotherhood and the Arab world has undergone upheaval since then. The Muslim Brotherhood abandoned the armed struggle and became a civil movement that supported Egyptian citizens come rain or shine. During Ramadan, it distributes food to the poor, and it is the first to arrive at the scene of disasters with food, tents, and modest financial aid to the survivors. It has learned, with its limited resources, to offer citizens the main asset that the regime took away - empathy.
The Muslim Brotherhood's move from the opposition benches to positions of leadership has caused an internal storm. The movement must adopt a new language and updated political platform. Although Palestine will be pushed aside a bit in favor of existential problems, the new reality is liable to strain relations between Cairo and Jerusalem.
When Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu mentioned the window of opportunity to free Gilad Shalit from Hamas, he saw this script in front of him - the Muslim Brotherhood taking the reins of power. However, it is premature to dump the Israel-Egypt peace treaty into the dustbin of history.
Although the Muslim Brotherhood has in past said that Israel is an illegitimate entity, its entry into politics has been accompanied by flexibility on this point. The Justice and Freedom Party, which represents the movement in the elections, has stated that it will honor "all international agreements and treaties" signed by Egypt. This clause is mainly directed at Israel.
Whatever Egyptian government that is formed will face serious challenges. The most difficult of all is economic recovery. The Egyptian revolution has incurred a heavy economic price, driving away tourists and investors. The country's currency reserves for 2012 are at a nadir, and the Cairo Alexandria Stock Exchange has lost billions of dollars in value this year. Cairo's economy largely depends on tourism, gas exports to Israel and Jordan, and taxes on transit of the Suez Canal.
Severing relations with Israel would be an act of national irresponsibility that would sabotage Egypt's existential interests. Except for fringe groups, the Egyptian public knows the advantages of the peace treaty, and is not demanding its government to abrogate it.
The Egyptian government will also need Israel's help in the difficult problem that has been developing in Sinai since the revolution in Cairo. The border zone with Gaza has become uncontrollable, where extremists seeking to seize power, operate. In the future, a Muslim Brotherhood government could serve as a more effective mediator than any of its predecessors in the difficult issues between Israel and Hamas.
One question that is still open is the future status of the Egyptian Army in politics. Its officers are striving to serve as an unofficial super-authority, a kind of shield of democracy if needed, similar to the Turkish Army. In the Kemalist era, Turkish generals carried out three coup d-etats, citing threats to national security or that democracy was falling into Islamic hands.
The Islamic parties running for election in Tunisia, Morocco, Egypt, and even Hamas in the Gaza Strip, are remote from the Jihadists of Bin Laden and the Taliban. While it is possible to see the rise of the Islamic parties as a threat to Middle East peace, the fear is overblown. In the long term, the process will likely be seen as an important stage in Arab societies' transition from the grip of tyranny. After trying and failing to seize power through violence, political Islam has grown up from a bad boy into a responsible adult.
The writer is the Arab Affairs commentator for “IDF Radio" (Galei Zahal).
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on November 29, 2011
© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2011
You comment was recieved and soon will be published.
Thank you for posting your comment, which will be reviewed for publication.
Load more comments
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu threatens "dire consequences" following the kidnapping.
Questions over police response to kidnapping
Hours passed before a search operation was launched. Netanyahu holds Palestinians responsible.
Netanyahu bought furniture at public expense - report
"Yediot Ahronot": Attorney General is investigating if Netanyahu family bought furniture for its Caesarea private home.
Binyamin Ben-Eliezer questioned by police again
Ben-Eliezer's son Yariv is also suspected of receiving money from Avraham Nanikashvili.
Reuven Rivlin elected president
Rivlin defeated Meir Sheetrit 63:53 in the second round vote in the Knesset.
Meir Sheetrit discloses owning five homes
The Presidential candidate has bowed to public pressure and declared his assets.
Police find $600,000 cash in Ben-Eliezer's bank
The source of the money found in Binyamin Ben-Eliezer's safety deposit box is unclear.
Presidential candidate Ruby Rivlin discloses assets
Dalia Dorner also disclosed her wealth, but Meir Sheetrit refused.
Dalia Itzik bought Tel Aviv home for NIS 4.6m last year
The Presidential candidate and former Knesset Speaker also owns two apartments in Jerusalem.
The venture capitalist who wants to transform Israel
Labor MK Erel Margalit tells "Globes" about his plans to improve the Start-Up Nation.
Combat cameramen disprove Palestinian propaganda
A unit of highly trained combat soldiers uses cameras to document military operations.
Truth is proving stranger than folktale as Turkey's spins out of Prime Minister Erdogan's control.
Prof. Zvi Eckstein supports NIS 3.30-3.40/$ floor rate
The former deputy Bank of Israel Governor is the first senior figure from the financial system to advocate a floor rate.
2014 will be year of change
Forces reshaping the Middle East are coming to a head, with Russia taking a close interest, and the West seemingly indifferent.
Gains and losses for Middle East secularists
Recent developments in Egypt, Syria and Turkey have clarified some issues, and obfuscated others.
Developing robots for warfare
Israeli research sees the future battlefield dominated by robots and unmanned devices.
Geneva changes Middle East strategic map
As the consequences of the nuclear agreement with Iran emerge, regional powers are scrambling to adapt.
Egypt has no time to lose
Unless economic reforms are introduced quickly, the country is liable to relapse into Islamic extremism.
Strange goings on in Turkey
Two recent decisions by Turkish prime minister Erdoğan make it look as though he is losing his grip.
See you in six months, Rouhani
Israel may look isolated over the nuclear deal with Iran, but the cards could yet fall its way.
China is changing
The Third Plenum of the Communist Party of the Peoples' Republic of China marks a turning-point in all areas of Chinese life - with consequences for Israel.
French gov't proposes building 2 Tel Aviv light rail lines
The Green Line from Herzliya to Holon and the Purple Line from Kiryat Ono to Tel Aviv would cost NIS 30 billion to build.
Israel's factious coalition looks wobbly on Iran
Besides US opposition, the state of Israel's government makes an attack on Iran unlikely.
Budget cuts threaten 10,000 defense industry jobs
Senior executives warn many factories are in danger of closing due to the drying up of defense ministry's orders.