Netanyahu: The boys were kidnapped by Hamas
The company is based beyond the Green Line. The Presbyterians voted narrowly not to divest from Caterpillar, Motorola, and HP.
The 220th General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the US, which has 2.3 million members, entered the Middle East mire last Thursday, with three decisions at its meeting in Pittsburgh, after months of debate and feverish lobbying by pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian groups. The General Assembly voted to boycott Ahava Dead Sea Laboratories Ltd. and Hadiklaim Israel Date Growers Co-operative Ltd. because the companies are based beyond the Green Line, but it voted against labeling Israeli policy toward the Palestinians as apartheid, and against divesting from Caterpillar Inc. (NYSE: CAT), Motorola Solutions Inc. (NYSE: MSI), and Hewlett Packard Inc. (NYSE: HPQ).
The inconsistency reflects efforts by the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church to formulate what it considers a balanced position on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As dozens of delegates said during the meeting, the Presbyterian Church did not want to be seen as an anti-Israel organization, but at the same time, it wanted to protest against what it sees as ongoing injustice against the Palestinians. The result was a conceptual mishmash which disappointed both Israel's friends and its critics.
Before the votes on Ahava and Hadiklaim, Reverand Jack Baca, moderator of the committee on Middle East Peacemaking, called it "an attempt to communicate our hope for signs of progress and that the proposed boycott would be temporary."
Opponents of the boycott of Ahava and Hadiklaim said that a boycott was not constructive and would not contribute to solving disputes. One delegate said he opposed the boycott because his dermatologist highly recommended Ahava products. However, Marilyn Daniel, an elder from Kentucky, spoke for the majority when she said the boycott was "a narrow and focused action which clearly states we are opposed to Israeli settlement on the West Bank ... It is not a broad and general condemnation of Israel."
The vote to boycott the two companies was 457 to 180. In another vote, the commissioners voted 463-175 against labeling Israeli policy toward the Palestinians "apartheid." The Middle East committee opposed the label, saying that while the policies were wrong, they did not fit the United Nations race-based definition of apartheid. The vote against divestment of Caterpillar, Motorola, and HP was a razor-thin 333-331, with two abstentions.
In 2011, a Presbyterian Church committee concluded that Caterpillar sells military bulldozers to Israel which are used to demolish Palestinian homes, that Motorola sells monitoring and surveillance equipment to Israel which are used against Palestinians living in the West Bank, and that HP sells to Israel biometric scanners used to identify Palestinians at roadblocks and technology used by the Israel Navy in its blockade of Gaza.
The decision not to divest from the three companies is a setback for the Palestinian Divest, Boycott and Sanctions (BDS) Movement, which calls for economic pressure against Israel to persuade it to end the occupation of Palestinian territory, similar to the campaign against apartheid in South Africa.
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on July 8, 2012
© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2012
You comment was recieved and soon will be published.
Thank you for posting your comment, which will be reviewed for publication.
Load more comments
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu threatens "dire consequences" following the kidnapping.
Questions over police response to kidnapping
Hours passed before a search operation was launched. Netanyahu holds Palestinians responsible.
Netanyahu bought furniture at public expense - report
"Yediot Ahronot": Attorney General is investigating if Netanyahu family bought furniture for its Caesarea private home.
Binyamin Ben-Eliezer questioned by police again
Ben-Eliezer's son Yariv is also suspected of receiving money from Avraham Nanikashvili.
Reuven Rivlin elected president
Rivlin defeated Meir Sheetrit 63:53 in the second round vote in the Knesset.
Meir Sheetrit discloses owning five homes
The Presidential candidate has bowed to public pressure and declared his assets.
Police find $600,000 cash in Ben-Eliezer's bank
The source of the money found in Binyamin Ben-Eliezer's safety deposit box is unclear.
Presidential candidate Ruby Rivlin discloses assets
Dalia Dorner also disclosed her wealth, but Meir Sheetrit refused.
Dalia Itzik bought Tel Aviv home for NIS 4.6m last year
The Presidential candidate and former Knesset Speaker also owns two apartments in Jerusalem.
The venture capitalist who wants to transform Israel
Labor MK Erel Margalit tells "Globes" about his plans to improve the Start-Up Nation.
Combat cameramen disprove Palestinian propaganda
A unit of highly trained combat soldiers uses cameras to document military operations.
Truth is proving stranger than folktale as Turkey's spins out of Prime Minister Erdogan's control.
Prof. Zvi Eckstein supports NIS 3.30-3.40/$ floor rate
The former deputy Bank of Israel Governor is the first senior figure from the financial system to advocate a floor rate.
2014 will be year of change
Forces reshaping the Middle East are coming to a head, with Russia taking a close interest, and the West seemingly indifferent.
Gains and losses for Middle East secularists
Recent developments in Egypt, Syria and Turkey have clarified some issues, and obfuscated others.
Developing robots for warfare
Israeli research sees the future battlefield dominated by robots and unmanned devices.
Geneva changes Middle East strategic map
As the consequences of the nuclear agreement with Iran emerge, regional powers are scrambling to adapt.
Egypt has no time to lose
Unless economic reforms are introduced quickly, the country is liable to relapse into Islamic extremism.
Strange goings on in Turkey
Two recent decisions by Turkish prime minister Erdoğan make it look as though he is losing his grip.
See you in six months, Rouhani
Israel may look isolated over the nuclear deal with Iran, but the cards could yet fall its way.
China is changing
The Third Plenum of the Communist Party of the Peoples' Republic of China marks a turning-point in all areas of Chinese life - with consequences for Israel.
French gov't proposes building 2 Tel Aviv light rail lines
The Green Line from Herzliya to Holon and the Purple Line from Kiryat Ono to Tel Aviv would cost NIS 30 billion to build.
Israel's factious coalition looks wobbly on Iran
Besides US opposition, the state of Israel's government makes an attack on Iran unlikely.
Budget cuts threaten 10,000 defense industry jobs
Senior executives warn many factories are in danger of closing due to the drying up of defense ministry's orders.