Three IDF paratroopers killed in Khan Younis
Israel may look isolated over the nuclear deal with Iran, but the cards could yet fall its way.
By now, just about every commentator, academic, pundit, journalist and politician has had his or her say about the "breakthrough agreement" or alternatively, "historic mistake" or "potential cataclysmic disaster", depending on the point of view.
It cannot be all of those things simultaneously. True, it is better than the previous draft torpedoed by the French, but is it good enough? True, it temporarily slows down the process of enriching uranium--but does not reverse it. True, it halts progress on the plutonium facility being built in Tarik--but it doesn't require its dismantlement. True, it provides for daily inspections by the IAEA and sets up (yet another) international commission to supervise the IAEA process--but it doesn't permit unannounced inspections.
In any case, all of the above is only significant if Iran faithfully does what it has promised to do. On the other hand, even if it does, it will have six months to await the collapse of the crippling sanctions (according to the critics) and be able to provide oxygen to its suffocating economy through immediate relief provided by US$7 billion of revisions to the sanctions regime, which will take place before the Iranians have down anything at all.
Or, of course, the immediate relief is simply a teaser, which will help to convince Tehran that it is essential to regime survival to observe the terms and conditions of the deal to the letter.
At any rate, the Munich--sorry--Geneva accord has been endorsed by one and all, even including tepid endorsements by Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and the UAE (but with a sour statement from Kuwait), with two significant exceptions (Canadians will consider their government's denunciation of the deal as significant also): the US Congress and Israel.
Leaders of both houses of Congress and of both parties have declared that they do not consider themselves bound by the deal, and that shortly after the Thanksgiving recess they will pass legislation actually strengthening the sanctions. Of course, President Obama has said he will veto any such bill put on his desk, and it is questionable whether the sponsors will be able to muster the two-thirds majorities required to override such a veto. Still, such a vote would be a serious setback for Obama and an equally serious warning to the Iranians.
In Israel, all significant political forces, with the exception of the new leadership of the Labor Party, and the great majority of the commentators have condemned the deal. But wait--maybe it's not such a bad thing after all--let's think a bit out of the box, as they say.... if six months go by and no overall final agreement is reached, and if (a big if) in the meantime the remaining sanctions hold, then all options are again on the table and instead of Israel being isolated, Iran would be. Hmmm. .
Norman A. Bailey, Ph.D., is Adjunct Professor of Economic Statecraft at The Institute of World Politics, Washington, DC, and a researcher at the Center for National Security Studies, University of Haifa.
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on November 26, 2013
© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2013
You comment was recieved and soon will be published.
Thank you for posting your comment, which will be reviewed for publication.
Load more comments
Moshe Ya'alon: Prepare for more substantial missions within the Gaza Strip.
80 flights to and from Israel canceled in 24 hours
7 foreign airlines, including British Airways, are still flying to Israel.
State Comptroller to examine tunnel preparedness
Josef Shapira will examine efforts to find a technological solution to the tunnels problem.
Transport Ministry urges airlines to resume flights
Transport Ministry director general: As of noon, 65% of the traffic to Israel was on schedule.
Michael Bloomberg flies to Israel
The former New York City Mayor is flying El Al to show solidarity, and protest suspension of US flights.
Foreign carriers suspend Ben Gurion flights
Only El Al, Arkia and Israir are flying to and from Tel Aviv today.
Budget constraints mean IDF using vulnerable APCs
An anti-tank missile hit an outdated APC early this week, killing seven soldiers.
Kerry backs Egyptian cease-fire initiative
The US Secretary of State said in Cairo that his aim was not just a cease-fire, but to deal with the underlying issues.
Al Jazeera: Liberman inciting against us
Foreign Minister Avigdor Liberman called for shutting down the Arab media network in Israel.
Israel denies cease-fire reports
Palestinian media report progress in talks in Cairo on an agreement beginning with a humantitarian cease-fire.
"Our technology can solve tunnel problem"
Magna CEO: Surrounding Gaza with sensors can detect tunnels, but it will cost billions.
Rocket fire continues
Sirens sounded in southern and central Israel this morning, as pressure for a cease-fire mounts.
15 terrorists killed after infiltrating through tunnel
The incident took place near Kibbutz Nir-Am. Netanyahu: Operations will be expanded as necessary.
13 Golani soldiers killed in Gaza fighting
This brings to 18 the number of IDF fatalities since the operation in Gaza began.
IDF sets up field hospital for Gazans
The hospital at the Erez Checkpoint will provide humanitarian treatment for Palestinians.
Hamas seeks temporary cease-fire after heavy losses
Israel agrees to two-hour cease-fire after dozens of Hamas terrorists were killed in fierce fighting in Gaza's Sejiya neighborhood.
IDF expands Gaza operation
Large Israeli forces entered the Gaza Strip last night; rockets were fired at Israeli cities this morning.
Netanyahu: We're ready to expand ground operation
"Without action, the price that we would pay would be much greater," the prime minister said.
IDF ground forces enter Gaza Strip
The IDF estimates that the operation to destroy terrorist tunnels will last at least 7-14 days.
Compensation for southern residents only
Compensation will be granted to parents and disabled who have difficulty reaching their place of work.
Israel thwarts major Gaza tunnel infiltration
Five terrorists were killed but eight others escaped back to Gaza.
US Senate approves $351m transfer for Iron Dome
The total aid to Israel for missile defense approved this week by the US amounts to $621 million.
Bennett: New angels law is world's most daring
"I don't know any other country that recognizes 100% of an investment for tax purposes in the first year."
Security situation adds to exporters' woes
Israel Export CEO: We'll see deals lost if the Gaza operation continues.
Cease-fire collapses as Hamas continues rocket fire
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has ordered the IDF to hit Gaza targets hard.
Israel accepts cease-fire
The security cabinet has accepted the Egyptian proposal for a cease-fire but Hamas continues firing rockets.
Michael Sarel: Many will die because of 0% VAT
The former Finance Minister chief economist said it will cost the economy NIS 50 billion.
IAF downs drone over Ashdod
The drone aircraft took off from the Gaza Strip and was shot down by a Patriot missile.
Gazans owe Israel Electric Corp. NIS 220m
The Gazan debt is part of NIS 1.5 billion owed by Palestinian electricity consumers.
Business Insider: Israel raises moral warfare standards
The ratio between IDF air attacks in Gaza and civilian fatalities is very low.