Budget dilemmas in Israel and the US

The most fateful decision by governments is the split between spending on defense, and spending on making the country worth defending.

In The United States, a broken political system and a broken budgetary process have resulted in an automatic, across-the-board budget cut for the approximately one-third of the governmental budget that is not mandated (social security, medicare, etc.), including defense and internal security. Although the amount is relatively small compared with the total budget since it is spread over ten years, the so-called "sequester" was adopted by Congress at the suggestion of the Obama Administration, precisely in order to avoid what just happened, the reasoning being that neither the executive nor the Congress would allow such an absurdity to take placew, forcing a budgetary compromise.

In Israel, whatever the composition of the new government coalition, after the surprising results of the recent election, it will be faced with the same kind of budgetary decisions, which short of war and peace, are the most difficult decisions to be made by any democratic government, which must respond not only to its own judgements but to preferences and pressures of society at large.

Of all the budgetary decisions which must be made, the most difficult of all is the allocations of the country's resources between defense and security expenditures on the one hand and everything else on the other. This is particularly acute in the US, because of its financial situation and its worldwide responsibilities, and for Israel, because of its geo-political situation and the kinds of public dissatisfaction demonstrated by the sit-ins of 2011 in the major cities and the controversy over elements of the population that are accused of avoiding contributing to the country's resources--indeed, being a drain on them.

This can be expressed as a decisional conflict between what is devoted to defending the country and what is devoted to creating and strengthening a country worth defending. I and colleagues are engaged in a study for the Center for the Study of National Security of Haifa University, on this very problem, based on three case studies: Israel, a case of extreme centralization of the budgetary process; The United States, a case of extreme decentralization of the budgetary process, bordering on chaos (as graphically demonstrated by the "sequester"), and an intermediate case, The United Kingdom.

In Israel, the decision between defense and internal security, and everything else, is basically made through negotiation among three governmental departments: the Ministry of Defense, The Ministry of Finance and the Office of the Prime Minister. In The United States, literally hundreds of entities influence budget decisions: executive branch departments and agencies, as well as divisions within those departments and agencies; various committees and caucuses in both the House of Representatives and the Senate; hundreds of trade and professional associations, corporations, financial institutions, non-governmental agencies, and so on, who spend hundreds of millions of dollars in direct lobbying of both the executive and the Congress, or indirect lobbying through dozens of lobbying, public relations and law firms, as well as attempting to influence public opinion in general. Under the circumstances, exacerbated by a gigantic deficit and accumulated debt, it is hardly surprising, although greatly disturbing, that there has not been a federal budget actually approved since 2009! Even the effort made through the sequester process to force a decision failed to work, as noted above.

As the situation in the Middle East becomes more and more complex and threatening, but at the same time, pressures for ameliorating the economic situation of the middle class, young people starting their careers and minorities increases, and income disparities become wider, the political choice in Israel of a defense minister, a finance minister and of course a prime minister looms very large over society as a whole.

May the Almighty guide their deliberations!

Norman A. Bailey, Ph.D., is Adjunct Professor of Economic Statecraft at The Institute of World Politics, Washington, DC, and a researcher at the Center for National Security Studies, University of Haifa.

Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on March 7, 2013

© Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2013

View comments in rows
Update by email about comments talkback
Your name
Please insert your name
Hyperlink in a new window Hyperlink Right Left underline italic bold Bulleted List Ordered List Face1 Face2 Face3 Face4 Face5 Face6
Your comment

You comment was recieved and soon will be published.
In posting comments, I agree to abide by the Terms of Use
Globes encourages lively and frank debate, but posts that the editors consider merely abusive or otherwise inappropriate will be removed. Report inappropriate content
Thank you for posting your comment, which will be reviewed for publication.
Loading Comments...load
Load more comments
Benjamin Netanyahu Netanyahu: The boys were kidnapped by Hamas

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu threatens "dire consequences" following the kidnapping.

Benjamin Netanyahu Questions over police response to kidnapping

Hours passed before a search operation was launched. Netanyahu holds Palestinians responsible.

Benjamin and Sara Netanyahu Netanyahu bought furniture at public expense - report

"Yediot Ahronot": Attorney General is investigating if Netanyahu family bought furniture for its Caesarea private home.

Binyamin Ben-Eliezer  picture: Tamar Mitzpi Binyamin Ben-Eliezer questioned by police again

Ben-Eliezer's son Yariv is also suspected of receiving money from Avraham Nanikashvili.

Ruby Rivlin Reuven Rivlin elected president

Rivlin defeated Meir Sheetrit 63:53 in the second round vote in the Knesset.

Meir Sheetrit Meir Sheetrit discloses owning five homes

The Presidential candidate has bowed to public pressure and declared his assets.

Binyamin Ben-Eliezer  picture: Tamar Mitzpi Police find $600,000 cash in Ben-Eliezer's bank

The source of the money found in Binyamin Ben-Eliezer's safety deposit box is unclear.

Ruby Rivlin Presidential candidate Ruby Rivlin discloses assets

Dalia Dorner also disclosed her wealth, but Meir Sheetrit refused.

Dalia Itzik Dalia Itzik bought Tel Aviv home for NIS 4.6m last year

The Presidential candidate and former Knesset Speaker also owns two apartments in Jerusalem.

Erel Margalit The venture capitalist who wants to transform Israel

Labor MK Erel Margalit tells "Globes" about his plans to improve the Start-Up Nation.

IDF soldier Combat cameramen disprove Palestinian propaganda

A unit of highly trained combat soldiers uses cameras to document military operations.

Turkish bizarre

Truth is proving stranger than folktale as Turkey's spins out of Prime Minister Erdogan's control.

Prof. Zvi Eckstein supports NIS 3.30-3.40/$ floor rate

The former deputy Bank of Israel Governor is the first senior figure from the financial system to advocate a floor rate.

2014 will be year of change

Forces reshaping the Middle East are coming to a head, with Russia taking a close interest, and the West seemingly indifferent.

Gains and losses for Middle East secularists

Recent developments in Egypt, Syria and Turkey have clarified some issues, and obfuscated others.

Robot warfare Developing robots for warfare

Israeli research sees the future battlefield dominated by robots and unmanned devices.

Geneva changes Middle East strategic map

As the consequences of the nuclear agreement with Iran emerge, regional powers are scrambling to adapt.

Egypt has no time to lose

Unless economic reforms are introduced quickly, the country is liable to relapse into Islamic extremism.

Strange goings on in Turkey

Two recent decisions by Turkish prime minister Erdoğan make it look as though he is losing his grip.

See you in six months, Rouhani

Israel may look isolated over the nuclear deal with Iran, but the cards could yet fall its way.

China is changing

The Third Plenum of the Communist Party of the Peoples' Republic of China marks a turning-point in all areas of Chinese life - with consequences for Israel.

French gov't proposes building 2 Tel Aviv light rail lines

The Green Line from Herzliya to Holon and the Purple Line from Kiryat Ono to Tel Aviv would cost NIS 30 billion to build.

Israel's factious coalition looks wobbly on Iran

Besides US opposition, the state of Israel's government makes an attack on Iran unlikely.

Budget cuts threaten 10,000 defense industry jobs

Senior executives warn many factories are in danger of closing due to the drying up of defense ministry's orders.

Twitter Facebook Linkedin RSS Newsletters גלובס